American soybean growers, united in the American Soybean
Association (ASA) through a checkoff program pay a fee to the United Soybean
Board (USB) for promotion of their sector. Now ASA accuses the USB of wasting
ASA President John Hoffman (pictured) will ask Agriculture Secretary Ed Schafer to order an Office of Inspector
General (OIG) investigation and financial audit of the National Soybean Checkoff
The ASA petition calls for an investigation of the United
Soybean Board (USB) and the US Soybean Export Council (USSEC) to ensure that
soybean checkoff dollars are being managed and invested as prescribed by
"Serious ethical, legal, and financial
allegations have been raised about how farmer checkoff funds and program
activities are being conducted," said Hoffman, a soybean producer from Waterloo, Iowa.
- Improper and wasteful expenditure of both checkoff
and federal funds;
- Potential evasion of mandated salary and administrative
spending caps by USB;
- Conflicts of interests at USB;
- Use of checkoff funds for
prohibited purposes by USB; and
- Wasteful and excessive spending by USB.
Export council allegations
There are additional allegations concerning
improper USB oversight and tolerance of actions that have taken place at the
USSEC, an entity created by USB and ASA in October 2005.
- Improper conduct by a USSEC employee at USSEC functions;
- The firing of whistleblowers;
- Improper employee relationships;
- Management malfeasance and
- The inability of ASA Directors serving on USSEC Board
to obtain an independent and objective investigation of the
"With USB and USSEC, we are dealing with entities that
are spending tens of millions per year in soybean farmer checkoff dollars and US
taxpayer funds," Hoffman said.
"As the policy organization that
represents US soybean farmers, it is ASA's responsibility to ensure that the
soybean checkoff, and other entities the checkoff has created, are operating in
an accountable and transparent manner in the best interest of soybean
"ASA believes the national soybean checkoff, as currently
structured and operated, is no longer responsive and accountable to soybean
The failure of USB leaders to take decisive action on these
particular matters is indicative of how USB is no longer accountable and
responsive to the very soybean farmers who are paying funds into the checkoff
At the higher price and acreage levels experienced recently,
checkoff collections from soybean farmers in fiscal year 2008 are estimated to
exceed $140 million.
The United Soybean Board has responded to the allegations
saying this is " categorically untrue."
In a statement, the USB said,
"Today, US soybean farmers enjoy record demand both here and abroad for their
soybeans, through the fiscally responsible efforts of the farmers who serve
voluntarily on USB.
"If the US Department of Agriculture deems it necessary, USB welcomes a USDA Office of
Inspector General audit of any and all of its operations, contractor operations
To comment, login here
Or register to be able to comment.